-john
#2026
Posted 05 November 2010 - 10:37 AM
-john
#2027
Posted 05 November 2010 - 10:38 AM
#2028
Posted 05 November 2010 - 10:45 AM
#2029
Posted 06 November 2010 - 06:43 AM
-john
PS...using mini-motor parts, you can make some pretty high-revving scarey motors. If you have access to anyone with small machining capabilities, the best way I know of doing this is to have C-can endbells turned to fit and cut down the cans to use a short stack arm (around the length of the stock arm) for those short magnets. I've always nibbled-away at the endbells to get them to fit, but I'm sure there must be a more precise way to actually machine the endbell plastic accurately for a proper and centered fit. It probably involves a lathe and some way of securely chucking the endbell...after that, I'm lost.
#2030
Posted 06 November 2010 - 08:24 AM
Vic
#2031
Posted 06 November 2010 - 08:46 AM
If you have access to anyone with small machining capabilities, the best way I know of doing this is to have C-can endbells turned to fit and cut down the cans to use a short stack arm (around the length of the stock arm) for those short magnets.
John, I first saw this done about 10 years ago by Larry Shepard from CA. Larry did a "Plafit on Steroids" motor building article on OWH. He used a cut-down Mura C-can endbell & included drawings of his holding jig to turn them. I doubt they're still online. A few years later, Mike Swiss, while working at Koford, built Philippe some special motors to fit the TSRF chassis. Mike used the Koford C-can endbell because he said they were easier to cut down. So yes, it has been before.
I intend to live forever! So far, so good.
#2032
Posted 06 November 2010 - 09:28 AM
Yep...I've seen it around some, but without a lathe I've had to do it whatever way I could
-john
#2033
Posted 06 November 2010 - 11:45 AM
Back in the 70s when we were doing "P" cans which were the old FT130uo motors like the X88 with cobalts for pro motors. Some of my buddies in the UK, Ian Jensen and others, cranked out some specific endbells to do this with. Every so often, they show up somewhere. Worth looking for when building mosters. Russell Shelden and Dennis Samson have both used them.
In that period, the fun stuff was happening in England and South Africa.
John, you can do a decent job on the endbells without a lathe. If you have a good drill or drill press with a precise round chuck, you can gently turn it down that way. Do the final fit by hand as you have been and it will be fine.
Fate
3/6/48-1/1/12
Requiescat in Pace
#2034
Posted 06 November 2010 - 03:16 PM
If you have a good drill or drill press with a precise round chuck, you can gently turn it down that way. Do the final fit by hand as you have been and it will be fine.
...they have been fine.
-john
#2035
Posted 06 November 2010 - 04:34 PM
Duffy
1950-2016
Requiescat in Pace
And I am awaiting
perpetually and forever
a renaissance of wonder
#2036
Posted 06 November 2010 - 06:35 PM
If y'got anything good, please add.
??? Well there's more than a hundred pages worth of stuff and several thousand replies (some of it good) to be distilled Duffy...and I thought that's what you were planning. Turning endbells is probably near the bottom of this list for people who might be interested in tearing motors apart and rewinding
-john
#2037
Posted 06 November 2010 - 07:39 PM
--Well, the key word here is "It's a start" and indeed in my own files I've pulled threads from here and elsewhere and winnowed down, but they were for my own use and are uncredited in important ways, like names. Yes, I'm gonna do some distilling (and others're welcome to do too, very large hint here), and it will be on a hobby-oriented schedule.
And, as a 'start,' turning endbells is no more random than, or, or...and if anybody's got some time here on Date Night (we are slot racers, after all, let's be honest here), they can post some links to pertinent articles on Steve O'Keefe's site, how 'bout it guys?
Duffy, also building for Fall Brawl AND being a husband while he can
1950-2016
Requiescat in Pace
And I am awaiting
perpetually and forever
a renaissance of wonder
#2038
Posted 06 November 2010 - 10:35 PM
AH!! Thought you had a LIVE ONE, did ya? Hee hee hee hee!!
No not at all
And, as a 'start,' turning endbells is no more random than, or, or..
It's good info for the few who might have the equipment to do it and want to mess with it, although I'm pretty sure that those who already have a lathe would be able to rig an endbell for turning on their own. I would think starting at the beginning (more basic stuff) would be helpful for more people? For instance, there are some places back in all those pages where there are step-by-steps with pictures and gory details. Sadly, there are also folks here who know a thing or two about motors but aren't likely to divulge anything important, but we can muddle through I suppose. Then guys like Cheater and Bill know gobs about motors...as do Ron, Philippe etc. It would be extra groovy to see stuff from them too.
You mentioned Steve O'Keefe's site, well that's EZ enough:
Steve O'Keefe's "The Independant Scratchbuilder"
Wall-to-wall goodness there for sure, and from one of the best there is too!
-john
#2039
Posted 07 November 2010 - 10:21 AM
Let me restate, with new emphasis:
So often we think we're writing what we mean/so often we think we're reading what we mean.
--that latter part, I think, is what's happened in John's reading of my suggestion.
You know, I'm always bemused by those guys who go "Someone should write a tutorial on..." I always find myself thinking, yah, right, fella, it'd be nice for someone to help out, what part of our time shall we set aside to save your time? But here I've volunteered that very thing.??? Well there's more than a hundred pages worth of stuff and several thousand replies (some of it good) to be distilled Duffy...and I thought that's what you were planning. // you did bring it up though and then I said I wished someone would have done this a long time ago!
John didn't intend to organize a great tome, he started discussing Arm Winding--that's his hobby, and like any of us who do the work to explain & photo for this Blog, part of that hobby's in the communication--but not the major part: that quantity varies with the individual. Me, I got interested in seeing this thread and how-many-others presented in an accessible way that I would like to see, and said I'd give it a start. That's part of my hobby.
The key words, endemic to most hobbyists I know, are stated above: meager and random. Those qualities define the time and effort hobbyists spend on their stuff, and the great thing about hobby time, spotty as it might be, is: it's our choice in how we spend it.
The first two things I set into the F'Tech thread were entirely random. Sure, turning endbells may be one small trick and insignificant to many when compared to all the rest, but at that moment it was right there: I'd done the search & found the page, copied it into Word and edited it to conveniently fit the page spacings, converted to .pdf and uploaded. Half-hour, maybe forty minutes incl. sipping coffee and going back over. The Simco pamphlet I'd done for myself months ago. An hour, tops, online, out of my hobby; my choice.
If there's a common theme in Michael's (I'm not Duffy right now) life, it's truly this: my choices have never fared real well in the close focus of others.
Can't help that.
I suspect we all find a little of this in our experience, as well as the converse: in the long run, be ready to have your expectations ground down by others' failings to perceive, appreciate, or deliver.
I'm putting up an FT16 build I broke out of (I believe) this thread, edited down and .pdf'd. For the record & for perspective, ~2.5 hours, my hobby time. I'm presently working on John's very nice sequence of winding that he did for Ernie a while back, and when it's done I'll upload it. I'm not committing to anything more at this time and invite any of you to help, if you like--if it's worthwhile, we will do the job we enjoy doing on it. But I regret my part in anyone's reading that this would be a timely and comprehensive effort. I just can't promise to satisfy the expectations of even one other person.
1950-2016
Requiescat in Pace
And I am awaiting
perpetually and forever
a renaissance of wonder
#2040
Posted 07 November 2010 - 10:34 AM
Remember, two wrongs don't make a right... but three lefts do! Only you're a block over and a block behind.
#2041
Posted 07 November 2010 - 10:50 AM
All this is my way of saying that I spend considerable time and effort doing this stuff (in the hope of one day being really good at it!) and trying to motivate others to at least try it as well. Like yourself and probably most others here, my life is really "complicated" so I don't have any "spare time" (what is that anyway?) to put more effort into this thing. I do apologize for mis-reading your intentions here, but maybe we can both continue to just try and help as well as answer people's questions. A few people here and there along the way are bound to let their curiosity get the best of them!
-john
#2042
Posted 07 November 2010 - 12:45 PM
What another "jewel" of a motor - fantastic job!!! So you did this one out of a C-Can - I would've liked to see my D-Can walnut you built for me, juxtaposed with this "new and improved" Walnut to compare the difference in size. For me, it's always exciting to see not only John' work but to also mention most recently, Robert's rewinds. Also, not to forget everyone else's rewinding contribution. Everyone's sharing of their rewinds is such a motivation and inspiration!!
Thanks everyone for sharing your work!
Ernie
#2043
Posted 07 November 2010 - 04:06 PM
Yours and most of the others I've done were cut down C-cans. This one was done using some weird motor that was in a bunch of stuff Barney sent and is much smaller than the cut-down C-cans. It started out around the same width and height as a TSRF/Falcon sized motor...but much shorter than those. It's teensy
-john
#2044
Posted 07 November 2010 - 05:51 PM
Ernie
#2045
Posted 07 November 2010 - 06:30 PM
...nope, smaller still...but getting closer :-)
-john
#2046
Posted 07 November 2010 - 06:47 PM
He brought us up teaching us rewinding and other electronic skills. I guess I picked up some of it but, I was never as good as him. I got hold of the mechanical skills very well but, electronics were a stretch for me. Over the years I have rewound a few arms and some were good and some went up in smoke immediately.
One of my questions for you would be, what would you say is the main cause for the rewind burning up? I know you have stated that there is a big difference between what you did in the 60's and what you're doing now. Is there a special method or way you go about it that insures success?
Thanks! Really enjoying the read, just wish I had more time to do more reading here.
Z
#2047
Posted 07 November 2010 - 08:58 PM
It really nice to hear about you and your Dad
1)Just not knowing what we were doing...or doing "it" too much. My first digging-in came in the form of de-winding and the worst thing that could happen was some success. The reason being that, if a little de-winding was good...then a lot of dewinding MUST be better...POOF!
2)Materials were often terrible. Mabuchi motors in general were awful things, although they do have a certain charm now. The coms were flimsy as heck, the magnets wouldn't hold a note on a fridge, the springs were weaker than what came in ball point pens...and the endbells were made of something not much more heat resistant than candle wax. Still...it was fun!
3)Shorts were a constant problem, and jamming as much wire on the arm as you could fit with a stick didn't help
4)Even if you got a hotter wind to hold together and actually work, soldered com connections were prone to failing.
There's probably more I'm not thinking about and even some stuff that still burns up motors like improper gearing loading a motor and causing it to overheat and fail. Most of the material problems have been solved for home-winding as even a stock C-can can take some serious muscle. I also have greater success when I use better materials. Recycled coms mostly work fine, but with a hot wind they can fail without warning. As well as furnace cement works as a stack insulator, it's still not as good as the coatings used now. I'm also a lot more careful about neatness when winding...especially lately with some side stuff I'm trying with modern hot motors. Neatness and consistency from pole-to-pole counts for a LOT with winding motors. First because it means that each pole is more likely to behave exactly like the other two. Second, I believe (but have no way of knowing) that neatly wound coils produce a more focused field. I also try to have as much wire on the outer part of the arm as I can, figuring that also puts more field where you need it. Again though, I have no way of knowing that for sure as I have education or industrial experience with this stuff.
I still burn up motors but less of them and they last longer on average even if they do smoke. Then again, all high performance motors are ticking time bombs. If you want to have fun and wind motors, start with good supplies and materials and that will help a LOT. After that, ask questions and be as neat and careful as you can. I can wind motors that aren't "on the edge" and pretty consistently have them do what I want them to, but that's not what I like to do most. I really would like to get more consistent at making HAIRY arms that last and that's what I'm chasing.
-john
#2048
Posted 08 November 2010 - 09:05 AM
I also wanted to ask how you prepare the wire to weld or solder? Isn't there a "varnish" or coating on most wire that has to be removed in order to get a good connection?
Z
#2049
Posted 08 November 2010 - 09:22 AM
Theoretically, the short but intense heat for brazing should vaporize the coating but I work under the assumption that some carbon left from the burned coating might remain contaminating the connection. I scrape the magnet wire where it crosses over the com tabs before brazing. I also make sure that the tabs themselves are clean and free of oxidation because I want the current to pass easily when brazing. So I treat the connection the same way I would if soldering. All these little things and a lot more are just my way of hoping to eliminate as many problems beforehand as I can. Over the course of a motor job they add up to a lot of extra time, but I think they help improve consistency and performance and avoid problems later on.
-john
#2050
Posted 08 November 2010 - 01:13 PM
I'm gonna try rewinding again sometime soon. We are running "open" classes now in the club so, I have the perfect opportunity to test.
Thanks!
Z



This topic is locked






