#2426
Posted 24 January 2011 - 04:21 PM
Yes, we have spoken here several times about these motors, and they are a very good platform for rebuilding. The endbell is lightyears better than the old Mabuchis for sure, but it uses "off-size" brushes and the spring arrangement (and type) is awkward. Also, the can seems pretty straight, but is on the weak/flimsy side. Truthfully, the Mabuchi can is much stronger...especially since it's a one-piece drawn can as opposed to the seamed/welded SCX can. The SCX can is MUCH lighter though and the SCX magnets (even though they're ceramics) measure very strong indeed...especially for such thin pieces.
-john
#2427
Posted 24 January 2011 - 06:03 PM

The finished motor sounds great, draws around 2 amps (with light springs), runs smooth and doesn't get very warm at all:

-john
#2428
Posted 24 January 2011 - 10:43 PM
I think you're hiding something!! You must have a "CAR" (Computer Aided Rewinder) LOL!!! Geez, I just sent you the motor the other day and like magic "POOF" - it's done!!
Awesome John - thank you so very much.
I'm always the envy each time I bring a new rewound motor from John to show the guys at the track.
Thank you again John. Your motors are cherished!!!
Ernie
#2429
Posted 24 January 2011 - 10:48 PM
May I ask you please, what does it take to "mod" the Mura Challenger II endbell to fit the SCX, F7, etc., type cans? Also, the next time you fabricate a set of buss bars, would you mind posting a few pix please? I have no idea where to start when it comes to fabricating buss bars and would like very much to see how it's done. IF - it isn't an inconvenience please.
Thank you John!
Ernke
#2430
Posted 25 January 2011 - 06:42 AM
Always a pleasure

I trace those on a piece of thin brass sheet and then add the extra material for the bussbars to them before cutting them out and drilling them. Afterwards, I smooth them out a little so they look nicer and remove any burrs by sanding/filing the edges and running them on sandpaper that I lay on my glass work surface. After test fitting and adjusting any cuts if necessary, you make your bends and mount them. Then I use an alignment tool to make sure the buss bar plates and hoods are on there straight, flip the endbell over and do any radiusing necessary to clear the commutator. Last thing I do is remove any burrs that formed from radiusing the inside. It's just simple tracing, cutting and fitting...but they're small and the brass bends easily so you have to be a little careful is all.
Other than the bussbars, the endbell is C-can sized and the SCX motor is pretty much the same width but even slightly less tall (from flat side to flat side) than the Falcon type mini motors. The outside diameter of the endbell needs to be taken down quite a bit to fit the SCX motor and the height (from flat to flat) needs to be slightly shortened.
-john
#2431
Posted 25 January 2011 - 12:06 PM
Thanks for taking the time to explain the process. If you please, what gauge of brass do you use or recommend? I have a few pieces of brass but they look sort of thick.
After test fitting and adjusting any cuts if necessary, you make your bends and mount them.
Do you use pliers to bend them or do you use something else so you don't leave the pliers teeth marks on them? I just tried to bend a brass piece using regular old pliers but left some marks on the brass.
Thank you again for your time and patience in answering my questions John!
Ernie
#2432
Posted 25 January 2011 - 12:37 PM
I browsed this thread and noticed that buss bars are fabricated from brass. Why not steel? Is there an advantage to using brass or is it a matter of preference?
Thank you.
Ernie
#2433
Posted 25 January 2011 - 01:20 PM
Do you use pliers to bend them or do you use something else so you don't leave the pliers teeth marks on them? I just tried to bend a brass piece using regular old pliers but left some marks on the brass.
I use a small set of needle nose pliers to make the bends as this material bends easily without having to grip it so hard.
If you please, what gauge of brass do you use or recommend?
Any brass that is strong enough will carry the current necessary. I've done it out of thick (I think .032") brass and that's a pain because the material is thick enough that you have to take the thickness into account when bending it or it won't fit the endbell properly. I've also done it out of brass about the same gauge as the Mura hardware...I think around .015", and that's MUCH easier to both cut and bend.
I browsed this thread and noticed that buss bars are fabricated from brass. Why not steel? Is there an advantage to using brass or is it a matter of preference?
I guess you could make them out of steel...thicker steel shim stock would probably be OK...but steel is much harder to cut and fabricate, and it rusts. For conductive parts, brass is the ticket, that's why all the prongs on electrical cords and lamp parts are made of 70/30 or "yellow brass". It's physically strong enough as well as being a very good conductor.
-john
#2434
Posted 25 January 2011 - 04:10 PM
I intend to live forever! So far, so good.
#2435
Posted 25 January 2011 - 11:48 PM
Hi Bill,
I had been thinking about wrapping tape on the plier jaws - thanks for the reminder!!
Ernie
#2436
Posted 26 January 2011 - 10:05 AM
Vic
#2437
Posted 26 January 2011 - 10:10 AM
Mr. Frank
Frank Elavsky
5/20/60-2/9/12
Requiescat in Pace
#2438
Posted 26 January 2011 - 01:02 PM
Sure thing, OK so here's what I got.
1)Removed Falcon magnets from the can you sent...I had to trash them to get them out, and cleaned-up the can
2)Removed another set of Falcon magnets from a different Falcon and cut the top and bottom of the can so it could slide into your can
3)Temporarily shimmed the cut-down Falcon can inside your can to center it side to side
4)Soldered the cut-down Falcon can in to your can and removed the shims holding it in place
5)Cut away as much of the Falcon can as I could so that was left was mostly just your original can and enough of the Falcon inside it to mount the Falcon magnets
6)Cleaned, deburred, polished the can and shim...washed with baking soda to neutralize any soldering acid left, cleaned with acetone to prep for installing magnets
7)Epoxy-in the Falcon neo magnets (JB Weld...I figure it might help with the field since it has powdered steel in it and is magnetic), re-oil the bearing and bushing
8)Cut down the X-12 armature's tail spacer so it can be mounted in this setup
The above was a real b-buster and I'm not sure it will be anything special...hard to tell. In a typical Falcon can, the neos measure as much as around 1200 on my gauss meter. In this setup with such an open can as this slingshot thing, they measure less than 1100...somewhere around 1080 or so. The Falcon armature is usually somewhere around .505" diameter and the airgap in those little motors is pretty tight. Using the X-12 arm, which is usually somewhere around .510" or even slightly over, the airgap is extremely tight in this setup...I can't believe the arm seems to clear the magnets after all the work getting the shims in there! There can't be any more than a couple of thousandths clearance between the arm and the magnets...but it spins and doesn't seem to be hitting! I think I'm going to polish the arm down a thousandth or two just to be sure it's not hitting.
So, you have a setup with lightweight and pretty strong magnets, but I'm not sure you couldn't have gotten top-shelf ceramic magnets to produce as strong a field. It's hard to tell because the sligshot can has so little metal, magnets lose strength. On the other hand, such a tight airgap should make up for the can's open design. It will be an interesting thing to see how this thing works...especially with an X-12 arm in there. Usually, short stack arms don't have good brakes, but have lots of rpms. All that's left for me to do now is to cut the com and throw in some brushes and springs to give it a test spin. BTW, I'm about out of brushes...if you have some I sure could use them when you get a chance. Anyway, I'll report back after I get the motor all together again. For now, here's a picture of the arm in the setup:

Here's a shot from the can end to give you an idea how tight the airgap is. It's a little hard to tell from the photo because the edge of the magnets is rounded...but it's TIGHT.

-john
#2439
Posted 26 January 2011 - 01:18 PM
Hi Vic!
Anyways, I used two endbells, one with the stock hardware and the other one I built myself using Mura brass hardware.
Would you have any pictures to share - PLEEEEEEEASE?
Thank you.
Ernie
#2440
Posted 26 January 2011 - 01:50 PM
-john
#2441
Posted 26 January 2011 - 02:35 PM
Looks like a "transformer" robot motor - so KOOL John!!!!
Hi Vic!
Would you have any pictures to share - PLEEEEEEEASE?
Thank you.
Ernie
Hi Ernie,
I'll see if I can get some pics for you when I get out to the shop. The motor I was talking about is gone, but you got lucky as I just built another one lol.
Vic
#2442
Posted 26 January 2011 - 06:50 PM
Thanks for the consideration and I do appreciate it. I'm looking forward to seeing the motor!!!
Thank you for your time!
Ernie
#2443
Posted 26 January 2011 - 07:20 PM
Hi Vic,
Thanks for the consideration and I do appreciate it. I'm looking forward to seeing the motor!!!
Thank you for your time!
Ernie
No problem Ernie, I,ll snap a few pics for you tomorrow.
Vic
#2444
Posted 27 January 2011 - 09:21 AM
Frank. I got the motor together and tested it out. It all seems fine and runs strong, drawing about 1.5 amps (or so) at 12V and not getting at all hot. It seems to have good torque and brakes (by feel) and all this with extra light springs. No doubt you could get some more out of it with either light or maybe medium springs, but you'll have to screw with that and see what's what. My only reservations about the motor really doesn't have anything to do with the setup, as it all surprisingly seems to work well (sometimes these kinds of things don't work as well in real-life as they seem like they might on paper)! The arm has some vibration (Mura?) so the balancing is probably not the best. The can bearing is nice and tight and the endbell bushing is too, so it's not either of those causing the vibrations. Some vibration is OK, but it can shorten brush life, increase current draw and decrease RPMs. Let me know what the motor specs are for these races, maybe another arm...OR...if it must be X-12 maybe you can get lucky with a smoother arm if you have some others to try out. If you do try other 12 arms, the tail spacer will need to be shortened as I did on this one. So...long story short, as is ...the motor runs strong and stays cool...whew!
-john
COOL John... Can't wait to try it.. Sounds like a boat load of work...
Thanks so much..
O... buy the way , could you send back that viper arm when you load it up and ship..
Thanks again... Mr. Frank
Frank Elavsky
5/20/60-2/9/12
Requiescat in Pace
#2445
Posted 27 January 2011 - 11:41 AM
Great talking with you this morning on the phone.
O... buy the way , could you send back that viper arm when you load it up and ship..
...absolutely. It's all packed -up already, but I won't get over to the Post Office until Saturday. Enjoy!
-john
#2446
Posted 28 January 2011 - 08:25 AM
Thanks again, John..
Mr. Frank
Frank Elavsky
5/20/60-2/9/12
Requiescat in Pace
#2447
Posted 28 January 2011 - 12:17 PM
-john
#2448
Posted 29 January 2011 - 10:27 AM
Like I thought, this was a really tight "tap-fit" using a block of wood and a little plastic mallet to "persuade" what was now a magnet shim into the Mura C can...but it went in. I also coated the outside of the "magnet shim" with JB Weld epoxy as well as the inside of the C can beforehand, leaving just enough "clean" space" on the sides to insert thin steel shims to center the magnet shim side-to-side in the C can (remember, the Falcon is a somewhat loose fit side-to-side). When I got it all the way into place, which was a little messy because of the epoxy, and made sure everything was well-centered, I cleaned the outside as best as I could with a little acetone, a toothpick and paper towel pieces and popped it into the easy bake oven for speed-curing the epoxy.
After coming out of the oven, I removed the temporary side shims...thankfully the places I left without epoxy worked and they came out with some effort. Now it was time to cut away as much of the Falcon can-end as I could to match the Mura C-can's profile, do some more cleaning-up and try and make it NOT look like the hack job that it is. After all done, the look is ...well...a C-can with a can shim (duh!). I installed the neos and the whole mess looks like this:


You can see by the end-photo both the little bit of slop that needed to be taken up as well as the slightly different radius of the two cans by the grey JB Weld bond-line between the two. You can also see that both are well-centered, but I proved that to myself by looking around for the largest diameter arm I could find and installing it in the can with a Mura endbell and the arm spins freely without hitting the magnets (whew!).
So was all this effort (and it is a significant amount of effort) "worth it"?...of course not. Even without taking any measurements, the setup would be (even at McDonald's pay scale) stoopid-costly, but this is after all fun. Anyway here's the details of the "post mortem":
1)The magnets measure the same or maybe a bit stronger than they did in the Falcon can...somewhere near 1250 on my meter. That's strong and compares favorably with a set of Red Dots.
2)The resulting can, shim and neos weighs about the same as the can with a set of Red Dots installed. You could probably get it down to weighing even very-slightly less by gluing in the neos (I have clips on them now) and cutting away more of the Falcon shim, but not enough to make it worth the effort.
3)The hole as it stands is about the same as it would be with a set of Red Dots, maybe a tad bigger or smaller (I didn't measure it)...but it's right about "there". As it stands, I could simply remove the neos and shim them even tighter since they're only in with clips.
Of course, there's more to how magnets will work in a given can than just raw gauss reading, things like the shape of the magnets...the "tips", the height, the length etc. can affect the field they produce and of course the shape and thickness of the can they're mounted in... and how that works with a given arm. Putting some blank arms in the setup and spinning them by hand sure seems ("by feel") to indicate that there's a lot of "magnetic muscle" in there...if that means anything. I'll have to wind an arm or two and install them to see if this all works as well, not as well, or better than just installing a set of good ceramic magnets...but even if it's nothing particularly "special", it was a fun project.
-john
#2449
Posted 29 January 2011 - 10:57 AM
Great work on that can in a can should be interesting to see the arm that goes in there, are you going to remove the cross bar on the c can and open the hole up on the falcon a little, is it worth the effort of course it is this stuff is like low cost therapy.
#2450
Posted 29 January 2011 - 11:11 AM
are you going to remove the cross bar on the c can and open the hole up on the falcon a little
If I were after low-weight I could, but I also could have used a much lighter C-can to start with. The design of the Mura (including the cross bar) is partially aimed at optimizing the magnetic field and I didn't want to screw with that and wind up with a motor that gausses lower than the Falcon here. I think the "potential" benefits (*if there are any...that remains to be seen) here are that the motor will pop right in to a car setup for a C can, the magnets are cheap...basically free because there are so many of these motors around and may actually work as well or even better (???), and you get a cool-looking motor where people will say stuff like..."what the heck is that?" ...one of the most important factors
In the end, this is just another way to use easily-available "stuff" to do neat things, and the TSR/Falcon/S7 motors are particularly cool for this. For lightweight and lotsa power, the "Strapnut" © type conversions of those motors are pretty freakin' cool. Here, I don't think the weight thing is so important???
-john



This topic is locked






